Start with the cleanest source that arrives when your building needs it, and leave the source that needs the most treatment for last. In a hot, humid place like Jackson, Mississippi, that usually means air-conditioning condensate first where a building has central air handlers and a cooling tower or irrigation to feed.
Rainwater comes next where a large roof meets steady non-potable demand. Greywater suits buildings with many showers, many toilets and staff to run a treatment system.
The order changes building by building, so the real answer comes from a monthly water balance: what each source supplies, month by month, against what each non-potable use needs. This article compares the three sources on timing, volume, water quality, treatment, energy and storage, using Jackson’s climate normals and federal guidance, and ends with a starting point for common building types.
The short answer: match the cleanest source to the nearest use
Each source has one use it fits best. Condensate fits cooling tower make-up, rainwater fits irrigation and, with treatment, toilet flushing, and greywater fits toilet flushing in buildings that make a lot of it.
EPA’s WaterSense at Work guidance asks three first questions of any onsite source: which end uses it could replace, whether its volume and timing can meet that demand, “particularly if the demand is seasonal,” and whether it can meet the use’s quality needs.
The table below answers those questions for the three sources at a glance.
| AC condensate | Rainwater | Greywater | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Comes from | Cooling coils of air handlers | Roofs, through gutters and downspouts | Showers, baths, bathroom sinks, sometimes clothes washers |
| Arrives | With cooling load: summer, peaking July and August in Jackson | In storms: wettest December to April, driest September and October | Every day the building is occupied |
| Volume driver | Air-conditioned area, humidity, outdoor air | Roof area and rainfall | Number of people who shower and wash |
| Quality concern (EPA) | Low, except medium for pathogens | Low for most measures | High for sediment, organic load and pathogens |
| Best first use | Cooling tower make-up | Irrigation; toilet flushing with treatment | Toilet and urinal flushing |
| Storage | A shared tank, kept short and disinfected | Days to weeks, between storms | No more than about a day |
| Main burden | Piping from air handlers; disinfection | Tank size and space | Treatment, testing and staff time |
What each source is, and is rainwater greywater?
Rainwater is not greywater. Greywater is used water from a building’s showers, baths, bathroom sinks and sometimes clothes washers; rainwater is runoff from the roof before anyone uses it; and condensate is moisture pulled out of the air by cooling coils.
EPA defines gray water as “wastewater from lavatory sinks, laundries, and bathing,” and adds that it “never contains wastewater from toilets or urinals and excludes wastewater from kitchen sinks.” The Department of Energy’s Federal Energy Management Program (FEMP) uses the same boundary in its alternative water guidance. Toilet and urinal waste is blackwater, a different and much harder source.
Condensate forms, as EPA puts it, when “water vapor in the air condenses as it comes into contact with an air conditioner’s cooling coils.” Most buildings send it from a drip pan to the sewer. FEMP notes that “a large amount of condensate can form on cooling coils in areas with hot, humid summers such as the southeastern United States.”
Stormwater from the parking lot is not roof rain
Runoff from paved ground is a different source from roof rain, even though both start as rain. FEMP says captured stormwater “normally requires more treatment than captured rainwater because it is exposed to additional pollutants from drainage systems and surfaces that may have hydrocarbons.” EPA’s quality table rates stormwater a high concern for sediment and lists pesticides and fertilizers among its other considerations. Keep parking lot and landscape runoff out of a roof rain tank unless the treatment is designed for it.
Other onsite sources worth a line in the review
EPA’s list of onsite alternative sources also includes stormwater from paved areas, foundation drain water, reverse osmosis reject water and cooling equipment blowdown. Hotels and laundromats have one more: laundry rinse water, which can be reused within the laundry cycle. This article stays with the three sources most buildings ask about, but a water review looks at all of them.
When each source arrives: a Jackson calendar
The three sources keep different calendars. Rain is heaviest from December through April and lightest in September and October; condensate follows the cooling season, which peaks in July and August; greywater follows the people in the building, whatever the weather.
Rain
The National Weather Service’s 1991 to 2020 normals for Jackson put annual rainfall at 57.35 inches. April is the wettest month at 5.84 inches and September the driest at 3.48, with October close behind at 3.80. NOAA’s monthly normals count about 75 days a year with a tenth of an inch or more, but only 4.6 such days in an average September.
Condensate
Condensate comes with the cooling load. EPA says it is “generated in highest volumes during periods of high cooling loads,” and the amount depends on “the cooling load, relative humidity, and make-up air volumes.” Jackson’s cooling degree days, a standard measure of cooling demand, run about 532 in July and 522 in August, still about 360 in September, and fall to about 126 in October. Normal daily highs in July and August are about 92 F.
FEMP draws the practical conclusion: “Cooling tower make-up water is needed the most during the hot summer months, when the largest amount of air handler condensate can be collected.” Supply and demand rise and fall together, which is rare in water reuse.
Greywater
Greywater keeps the building’s calendar, not the weather’s. A hotel makes more on full weekends, an apartment building makes it every morning and evening, and an office with no showers makes very little. That steadiness is its main advantage: a greywater system does not need to store water from one season for another.
What the calendars mean together
September is the month to watch. The roof collects the least, but the air handlers are still running hard, so condensate can cover part of the gap. A rain system that also takes condensate is less likely to run dry in early fall than one that takes rain alone.
How much each source can supply
Each source has a simple first estimate, and the site’s calculators use the federal rules of thumb for all three. The estimates are only as good as the inputs, so check each one against a meter or a measurement before you size anything.
- Rainwater: roof area × rainfall × 0.62 gallons per square foot per inch × capture efficiency (EPA’s method, with 80 percent the usual assumption). See the rainwater calculator.
- Condensate: 3 to 10 gallons per day per 1,000 square feet of air-conditioned space on cooling days, EPA’s range. See the condensate calculator.
- Greywater: people × (shower and bath + bathroom sink + laundry, if collected) × (1 − treatment loss). See the greywater calculator.
One building, three sources
All three calculators open with the same fictional building, the 96-room Pearlbank Hotel, so their default results can be compared directly.
| Source (fictional Pearlbank Hotel) | Calculator default inputs | Default result |
|---|---|---|
| Rain from an 18,000 sq ft roof | 57.35 inches; 80 percent capture | 1,403 gallons on an average day; 512,021 gallons a year |
| Condensate from air handlers serving 50,000 sq ft | 3 to 10 gallons per 1,000 sq ft; 180 cooling days | 150 to 500 gallons on a cooling day; 27,000 to 90,000 gallons a season |
| Greywater from about 134 guests | 16 gallons of shower and bath, 3 of sink water per guest; 10 percent loss | 2,291 gallons a day, against 858 gallons of flushing demand |
On paper, greywater is the largest and steadiest of the three. The fictional hotel’s water review still chose rain and condensate, sharing a tank of about 10,000 gallons that feeds drip irrigation, plus laundry rinse recycling.
Storage limits the rain and condensate system to about 900 gallons a day of usable water, and the laundry loop adds 400. Greywater for toilet flushing was screened and not chosen, because the existing building has no separate drain and supply piping. The example project walks through that decision.
Supply only counts where there is a use for it
A source is only worth collecting if a non-potable use sits close to it in time and place. In the fictional Pearlbank Hotel’s average day of 10,000 gallons, landscaping takes about 1,600 gallons, cooling and heating about 1,200, and guest rooms and restrooms about 3,000, which includes the toilets. Those three end uses are the only places reuse water could go, and each one points to a different source.
Landscaping is outdoors and seasonal, so rain and condensate fit it without new indoor piping. Cooling tower make-up peaks with the cooling load, which is exactly when condensate peaks.
Toilets are indoors and run every day, which suits greywater in a building with separate drains, or treated rain and condensate in one without. Write the uses down first, then look for the source that matches each one.
Why cooling towers like condensate
Water chemistry adds a reason to send condensate to a cooling tower. EPA describes condensate as “generally high-quality and free of minerals and total dissolved solids,” and FEMP calls its very low dissolved mineral content “ideal for cooling towers.” EPA explains that as cooling equipment evaporates water, dissolved solids build up and part of the water must be blown down and replaced, so low-mineral make-up water helps.
Rain is low in minerals too: FEMP says rainwater is “typically free of salts and other harmful minerals.” Greywater carries soaps and dissolved solids that a tower would concentrate, which is one more reason it is rarely the first choice there.
Why the condensate numbers vary so much
Two federal sources give very different scales for condensate. EPA’s WaterSense range of 3 to 10 gallons per day per 1,000 square feet is what the calculator uses. EPA’s National Water Reuse Action Plan summary, completed in July 2026, says that “in humid zones, a 100,000 square foot building” can produce “one million gallons of A/C condensate per year,” which works out to about 27 gallons per 1,000 square feet a day averaged over a whole year.
The gap reflects how much buildings differ in cooling load, humidity and outdoor air volume, the three drivers EPA names. Treat any published rate as a starting range. The condensate calculator’s own advice is the right next step: measure one air handler with a container and a timer on a humid afternoon before you size a tank.
Example (fictional). The Ridgefern Building is a three-story Jackson office with 36,000 square feet of air-conditioned space, a 12,000-square-foot roof and 300 workday occupants who flush about 1,152 gallons a workday. Its roof yields about 935 gallons on an average day. Its air handlers would yield 108 to 360 gallons on a cooling day at EPA’s range.
Its greywater is small.
With no showers and an assumed half gallon of bathroom sink water per person per workday, the greywater calculator gives 135 gallons a day against 1,152 gallons of flushing demand, or 12 percent. For this building the comparison points to rain and condensate together, feeding toilets through filtration and UV, with greywater left out. Every number here is a planning assumption for a fictional building.
Water quality and health risk, side by side
Rainwater and condensate start much cleaner than greywater, but none of the three is safe to use indoors without treatment. EPA rates greywater a high concern for sediment, organic load and pathogens, and rates rainwater and condensate low on most measures.
| Source | Sediment | Dissolved solids | Hardness | Organic load (BOD) | Pathogens | Other considerations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rainwater | Low to medium | Low | Low | Low | Low | None listed |
| Air handling condensate | Low | Low | Low | Low | Medium | May contain copper when the coil is cleaned |
| Gray water | High | Medium | Medium | High | High | Detergents and bleach |
What “low concern” does not mean
A low rating is not a clean bill of health. EPA notes that condensate “can grow bacteria removed from the air in the building,” and its table recommends disinfection for every source used indoors. Rainwater and condensate start clean, but warm, still water in a tank changes that, so all three sources need treatment matched to their use and a tank that does not hold water longer than it must.
Treatment targets put numbers on the difference
The Water Research Foundation’s 2020 Onsite Non-Potable Water System Guidance Manual, listed by EPA among its key onsite reuse resources, sets pathogen reduction targets by source. For indoor uses such as toilet flushing, greywater needs a 6.0-log reduction of enteric viruses, 4.5-log of protozoa and 3.5-log of bacteria. Roof runoff needs 3.5-log of bacteria, with no virus target and no data for protozoa.
The manual’s example roof runoff train is a single UV reactor; its example greywater train adds a membrane bioreactor ahead of UV.
The manual’s table has no row for condensate. EPA’s July 2026 action plan summary fills part of that gap. A study of condensate from 13 air handling units in North Carolina, Indiana, Texas and Florida found “the potential for microbial growth and metals leaching in untreated condensate collections.” EPA concluded that these systems need managing “similarly to other premise water distribution systems,” and that Legionella and other opportunistic pathogens can be controlled in condensate collection systems.
Metals, coils and cleaning water
Condensate’s specific risk comes from the equipment. FEMP warns that condensate “can also acquire heavy metals because of contact with cooling coils” and asks that coil cleaning water be kept out of the capture system. EPA’s treatment table makes the same point in three words: “Segregate coil cleaning water.”
Health risk in buildings where many people live
The 2025 comparative study in Frontiers in Environmental Science compared rainwater harvesting and greywater use for a house in Portugal. It warns that greywater use inside buildings “can entail significant health risks, especially in buildings for collective use,” such as student residences and hotels, and that the testing it requires is costly. Under the Portuguese rules it describes, rainwater systems need no analytical testing in normal operation, while greywater systems need a safety plan and a testing schedule.
Treatment each source needs for each use
The same source needs different treatment for different uses, and the same use needs different treatment from different sources. The deciding factor is how people are exposed: below ground, in a cooling tower’s drift, or in the spray from a flushed toilet.
| Use | Rainwater | AC condensate | Greywater |
|---|---|---|---|
| Subsurface or drip irrigation | Screens and first flush; EPA says it “may be used for irrigation without additional treatment” | EPA: “generally safe without additional treatment” for subsurface irrigation | The lowest treatment level; subsurface only where the local code allows |
| Spray irrigation | Filtration and disinfection | EPA: “first be filtered and disinfected” | Not by spray: EPA says never through conventional sprinkler heads |
| Cooling tower make-up | Filtration; FEMP says more treatment may be needed than for irrigation | EPA: generally fine for direct use “in cooling towers with biocide control”; FEMP adds disinfection of stored water | Possible after full treatment; rarely the first choice |
| Toilet and urinal flushing | Filtration plus UV (3.5-log bacteria target) | Filtration plus disinfection, as for any indoor use | A unit listed under NSF/ANSI 350 plus disinfection and a residual |
The table explains the order in the opening. Condensate and rainwater reach their best uses with a filter and a UV lamp, while greywater needs a biological treatment plant before it reaches any of its uses inside the building. ICC’s guide to the 2018 plumbing code reflects the same split: rainwater “is not required to be treated beyond filtration” and protection from sunlight in typical cases, while greywater for flushing must be treated by a system that complies with NSF/ANSI 350.
Energy, storage and space
Rainwater and condensate cost space; greywater costs energy and attention. That trade-off often decides the choice in an existing building, where space and staff are both limited.
Energy
The UK Environment Agency’s 2010 report on rainwater and greywater systems found operational energy and carbon intensities “higher than for mains water by around 40 per cent for a typical rainwater application, and over 100 per cent for most greywater applications.” Short retention greywater units were the exception, about 40 percent less carbon intensive than mains supply. Those are UK figures against UK mains water, but the ranking is the useful part.
The Frontiers study puts greywater treatment energy at around 1.8 kilowatt-hours per cubic meter, about 6.8 kilowatt-hours per 1,000 gallons, and notes that rainwater for the same uses needed no treatment in its case. For rain and condensate, most of the energy goes to pumping, which the UK report identifies as the main driver of operational carbon.
Storage
Storage rules differ by source, and they set the size of the equipment:
- Greywater: ICC’s guide says it “cannot be stored untreated in excess of 24 hours,” so tanks stay close to one day of use.
- Rainwater: the tank carries the building between storms, often days to weeks of demand, so it is the largest piece of the system.
- Condensate: it can share the rain tank, but FEMP warns that it “can potentially grow bacteria during the storage phase,” so the stored water needs disinfection before a cooling tower or any indoor use.
Space and service life
Rain needs room for a tank: about 10,000 gallons in the fictional Pearlbank design. Condensate needs a gravity drain line from each air handler to that tank.
Greywater needs separate drains from every shower and lavatory, a treatment skid in a cool room and a treated water riser to every toilet. The Frontiers study adds a service life gap: the main components of its greywater system last 15 to 20 years, against 40 to 50 years for the rainwater system.
Upkeep and what tends to fail
The sources also differ in who has to look after them and how often. FEMP’s maintenance schedule for a rain system is mostly inspection: weekly at the roof, gutters and inlet screen; monthly for the diverter, pump, overflow and controls; annually for the tank and the backflow preventer. The UK report cites a review of rainwater maintenance logs that found the pump “the most likely point of failure.”
Greywater asks for more. FEMP’s greywater program covers leaks and blockages, filter cleaning and replacement, disinfectant, controls and periodic flushing of the whole system. The UK report summarizes an earlier study that found “variable reliability,” filters needing regular cleaning, odor problems, and systems that “switched to mains back-up with users unaware of the failure.”
Condensate sits in between. Its collection lines and tank need the same disinfection and flushing as other building plumbing, and coil cleaning has to be scheduled with the capture system isolated. Add every reuse tank to the building’s water management program, and use the Legionella checklist as a starting point.
What each source does to the sewer and the storm drain
The sources also change what leaves the site. Greywater reuse cuts the flow to the sanitary sewer, because the same water is used twice before it drains. The Frontiers study notes that this “can cause problems in the drainage and treatment of wastewater” in public systems if it becomes widespread, a question few studies have addressed.
Rain harvesting cuts stormwater instead. FEMP says it can decrease “the amount of runoff flow and in turn runoff velocity, which reduces flooding and erosion.” Condensate that would have gone down a drain to the sewer cuts sewer flow by the amount captured.
On the bill, the source does not matter as much as the meter. In Jackson, JXN Water charges both water and sewer from water meter readings, so each gallon of metered city water a reuse system replaces lowers both charges, whatever the source. The water savings calculator does that arithmetic.
Combining sources: when two are better than one
Rain and condensate combine well, because their seasons complement each other and their treatment is similar. Rain and greywater combine poorly, because they compete for the same uses and have opposite storage rules.
The site’s tank sizing calculator shows the first pairing in its default example: the fictional Pearlbank Hotel’s tank takes about 1,560 gallons a day on average, roughly 1,403 gallons of rain and 160 of condensate averaged over the year. At 6 days of storage and a 5 percent margin it returns a 10,080-gallon tank, with 40 gallons a day of city water makeup against 1,600 gallons of irrigation demand. In September, when rain is lowest, condensate is still flowing.
A month-by-month check for the fictional office
The fictional Ridgefern Building shows the effect in numbers. Its roof supplies rain every month at 5,952 gallons per inch.
For condensate, the table spreads the condensate calculator’s midpoint season (234 gallons a cooling day for 180 days, 42,120 gallons) across the months in proportion to Jackson’s cooling degree days. That spread is a planning assumption, not a measurement. Flushing demand is 24,192 gallons a month.
| Month | Rain (gallons) | Condensate (gallons) | Together | Against flushing demand |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| June | 26,367 | 7,704 | 34,071 | 9,879 over |
| July | 29,879 | 9,320 | 39,199 | 15,007 over |
| August | 27,915 | 9,155 | 37,070 | 12,878 over |
| September | 20,713 | 6,308 | 27,021 | 2,829 over |
| October | 22,618 | 2,200 | 24,818 | 626 over |
| November | 26,189 | 347 | 26,536 | 2,344 over |
On rain alone, September falls about 3,479 gallons short and October about 1,574. With condensate added, both months clear the average demand, though October only narrowly.
Averages still hide dry weeks, so the tank and the city water makeup remain part of the design. Every figure here is for a fictional building.
The Frontiers study found the opposite for rain and greywater in a single house. Because both serve the same uses, a joint system “has no apparent advantages,” and the cost is close to the sum of two separate systems. It saw a case for both only where non-potable water must be available at all times in a drought-prone climate.
When sources do share a system, the strictest one sets the treatment. The Water Research Foundation’s manual says that systems using several source waters “need to be designed to meet the most stringent” targets. Sending greywater into a rain tank therefore turns the whole tank into a greywater system, with greywater’s storage limit and treatment burden.
Which source first, by building type
Building type predicts the answer better than any rule of thumb. The table below gives a starting point to test with the building’s own bills and measurements, not a conclusion.
| Building | Likely first source | Why | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hotel with central air handlers | Condensate, then rain | Steady summer condensate and irrigation demand; large roofs | Laundry rinse water may come before either; greywater needs separate piping |
| New apartment building | Greywater or rain for toilets | Daily showers match daily flushing; dual plumbing is cheaper before walls close | Staff time and testing for greywater; tank space for rain |
| Existing apartment building | Leaks and toilets, then rain for irrigation | Separating drains in occupied buildings is hard | Old toilets often save more than any reuse system |
| Office or clinic | Rain and condensate | Little greywater; weekday flushing; central cooling | Weekend stagnation in tanks |
| School | Rain | Large roofs; flushing on school days | Summer break; tanks need a summer operating mode |
| Restaurant | Usually none at first | Kitchen water is not greywater; small roofs | Efficiency in the kitchen pays first |
A few notes on the rows. In hotels, laundry rinse water often deserves a look before any of the three, because it is already inside the building and can be reused within the laundry cycle; see laundry water recycling. In new apartment buildings, the decision about separate drains has to be made before the walls close, which is why greywater appears there and not in the row for existing buildings.
Offices and clinics tend to have central air handlers, large flat roofs and flushing concentrated on weekdays, which is why rain and condensate pair well there. Schools have the same roofs but a long summer break, so a tank that sits full and warm for weeks needs a plan to circulate, drain or bypass. Restaurants spend most of their water in the kitchen, which is not greywater, so kitchen efficiency usually comes first.
EPA offers a screening tool for the same question. Its NEWR calculator compares source water options for onsite non-potable reuse by ZIP code, climate, building size and building type, using life cycle assessment and life cycle cost. EPA describes it as screening level, “not intended to provide a detailed engineering assessment,” and recommends it for buildings with 50 or more occupants.
Whatever the source, approval is local. EPA’s list of states with onsite non-potable reuse regulations or guidelines has 12 entries, and Mississippi is not one of them, so each project goes to the local building official and, where wastewater is involved, the health department.
Mistakes that send a building to the wrong source
Most poor choices come from skipping a step, not from bad equipment. These are the ones the sources above warn about most clearly.
- Reusing before saving. The Frontiers study says installing efficient devices “must always be the priority technical measure,” and cites Portuguese studies showing about 30 percent savings in existing buildings from efficient fixtures and simple flow changes alone. Every gallon saved first is a gallon no reuse system has to collect, treat and store.
- Choosing on annual totals. A roof that collects more than the toilets use over a year can still run dry for weeks. FEMP’s sizing method compares supply and demand month by month, and suggests weekly figures for a closer look.
- Ignoring the plumbing. The largest source on paper can be the hardest to reach. In the fictional Pearlbank example, greywater supply was more than twice flushing demand and was still set aside because the building lacked separate drains and supply piping.
- Treating condensate as clean enough for anything. EPA’s July 2026 summary found potential for microbial growth and metals leaching in untreated condensate, and FEMP warns about coil cleaning water. Low minerals do not mean low risk.
- Mixing sources casually. A shared tank takes on the strictest source’s treatment target and storage limit, as the Water Research Foundation’s manual makes clear.
- Oversizing storage. FEMP notes that bigger tanks cost more, and ICC’s guide asks for circulation to prevent stagnation. Holding water longer than the use requires adds risk without adding much supply.
- Skipping the measurement. Published condensate rates differ several times over between federal sources. One afternoon with a bucket and a timer at an air handler settles more than any table.
How to run the comparison for your own building
The comparison takes a year of bills, a roof plan, an equipment list and an occupancy count. Work through it in this order, and write each number down with its source.
- Find the demand. Use twelve months of water bills and the water use calculator to estimate flushing, irrigation and cooling tower make-up, month by month. Fix leaks and old fixtures first, because they change every number after this step.
- Estimate each source. Run the rainwater, condensate and greywater calculators with your roof area, air-conditioned area and occupancy. Measure one air handler’s condensate on a humid afternoon.
- Build a monthly balance. Put supply and demand side by side for all twelve months. Look hardest at September and October for rain, winter for condensate and low-occupancy weeks for greywater.
- Match source to use. Pair the cleanest source with the use that is closest to it in time and place, using the treatment table above.
- Check the plumbing and space. Confirm where drains, tanks, a treatment skid and a purple-pipe riser could go.
- Screen the options. For buildings with 50 or more occupants, run EPA’s NEWR calculator as a second opinion.
- Ask who approves it. Take a one-page description to the local building official before design starts.
For the details of each source, read how greywater toilet-flushing systems work, what it takes to flush toilets with rainwater and whether AC condensate is safe to reuse.
The how it works page describes the reuse loop Maredes, a Jackson, Mississippi company that designs compact water treatment and reuse systems for one building at a time, uses for every source. Its greywater recycling and rainwater and condensate capture services start from a water review with this monthly balance at its center. More articles are in the water reuse section, and you can describe your building to begin.
