Maredes homeRequest a water review
Menu

Reverse osmosis vs carbon filters: what each removes and what it costs

The reader questionShould you choose reverse osmosis or an activated carbon filter for drinking water, based on what is actually in your water?

A fine-mesh stainless tea strainer rests on the rim of a tank with the waterline crossing it, its handle and upper mesh dry above the surface and its round bowl below holding a few dark tea leaves against the mesh.

Choose by what is in your water, not by the technology. An activated carbon filter reduces chlorine and chloramine taste, many organic chemicals including trihalomethanes, and, where its listing carries the claim, lead or PFOA and PFOS; it does not remove dissolved salts such as sodium, nitrate or fluoride. Reverse osmosis removes those dissolved substances too, and because household units commonly include carbon stages, it covers both lists, at the price of a membrane, a drain connection and water sent down the drain. If your report shows taste, chlorine or disinfection byproduct problems, carbon usually fits; if it shows high sodium, nitrate, arsenic or total dissolved solids, reverse osmosis is the tool.

Maredes is a Jackson, Mississippi company that designs water treatment and reuse systems for one building at a time and chooses point-of-use treatment from a laboratory result. This guide compares the two technologies contaminant by contaminant, works through Jackson’s 2025 water quality report as a real example, and covers private wells, reject water, minerals and running costs. What the certification marks mean is covered in our guide to NSF/ANSI 42, 53, 58 and 401 certifications.

Reverse osmosis vs carbon filter: the difference in one table

Carbon holds chemicals on its surface; a reverse osmosis membrane lets water through and sends most dissolved substances to the drain. That single difference explains almost every line of the table below.

Activated carbon is carbon processed to have a very large internal surface. University of Nebraska Extension’s guide to activated carbon describes it as an adsorptive process “in which the contaminant is attracted to and held (adsorbed) onto the surface of the carbon particles”. Reverse osmosis (RO) pushes water through a semipermeable membrane under pressure. Nebraska Extension’s guide to reverse osmosis says RO membrane filters “frequently are used to reduce the levels of total dissolved solids and suspended particles”, and that carbon and sediment filters are “commonly used in conjunction with RO filters”.

Contaminant or problemActivated carbonReverse osmosis unit (with its carbon stages)Claim to look for on the listing
Chlorine taste and odorYesYes, in the carbon stageNSF/ANSI 42, Chlorine Reduction
ChloramineYes, with a chloramine claimYes, if the carbon stage is rated for itNSF/ANSI 42, Chloramine Reduction
TrihalomethanesYes, with a claimYes, with a claimNSF/ANSI 53 or 58, TTHM Reduction
Many solvents and pesticidesYes, with a claimPartly; the carbon stage does much of itNSF/ANSI 53, VOC Reduction
LeadSome carbon blocks, with a claimYes, with a claimNSF/ANSI 53 or 58, Lead Reduction
PFOA and PFOSYes, with a claimYes, with a claimPFOA Reduction, PFOS Reduction
Sodium, chloride, total dissolved solidsNoYesNSF/ANSI 58, TDS Reduction
NitrateNoYes, with a claimNSF/ANSI 58, Nitrate/Nitrite Reduction
FluorideNoYes, with a claimNSF/ANSI 58, Fluoride Reduction
ArsenicNo, for ordinary carbonPentavalent arsenic, with a claimNSF/ANSI 58, Arsenic (Pentavalent)
HardnessNoReduces it, but hard water shortens membrane lifeA softener (NSF/ANSI 44) for the building
Bacteria and virusesNoNot recommended for this use; feed it coliform-free waterUV (NSF/ANSI 55) or other disinfection
Rotten egg odor (hydrogen sulfide)Catalytic carbon, at low levelsNo; the gas passes the membraneOxidation and filtration
Sources: University of Nebraska Extension G1489 and G1490; CDC, About Choosing Home Water Filters; NSF drinking water treatment unit claim lists (checked November 22, 2026); Maredes treatment selector. A "Yes" holds only when the specific model's listing carries the claim.

The CDC’s filter guide puts the split in one line: “Filters that remove germs often do not remove chemicals, and vice versa.” It says RO “will remove some types of chemicals from water, including lead, copper, chromium, chloride, and sodium” and “may also reduce arsenic, fluoride, radium, sulfate, calcium, magnesium, potassium, nitrate, and phosphorous”. For carbon, the CDC says pitcher and refrigerator filters “often use activated carbon filters” whose “main purpose is to improve the taste and smell, rather than the safety, of water”, which is true of many models and not of those with health claims on their listings.

What activated carbon removes, and what it cannot

Carbon is the right tool for chlorine, chloramine and many organic chemicals, and it can reduce lead and PFAS when the model is certified for them. It does nothing for dissolved minerals, nitrate, fluoride or germs.

Chlorine, chloramine and taste

Nebraska Extension says carbon filtration “can be effective in removing chlorine, chloramines, and some disinfection byproducts”. EPA’s secondary standards page adds that granular activated carbon “will remove most of the contaminants which cause odors, color, and foaming”. On NSF’s listings, chlorine and chloramine are separate claims under NSF/ANSI 42, so a filter rated for chlorine is not automatically rated for chloramine. Our treatment selector notes that ordinary carbon sized for chlorine “removes chloramine slowly” and that catalytic carbon with a chloramine claim and longer contact time is the usual choice.

Disinfection byproducts and other organic chemicals

Disinfection byproducts form when the chlorine or chloramine a utility adds reacts with natural organic matter in the water. EPA’s disinfection byproducts rules limit two groups: total trihalomethanes (TTHM) and five haloacetic acids (HAA5). The national standards set them at 0.080 mg/L (80 ppb) and 0.060 mg/L (60 ppb). Nebraska Extension lists TTHM among the compounds removed by the carbon filter in a household RO system, along with solvents such as benzene, carbon tetrachloride and trichloroethylene and pesticides such as atrazine.

NSF’s claim list includes “Trihalomethanes (TTHM) Reduction” under both NSF/ANSI 53 and 58, but no claim named for HAA5. For haloacetic acids, ask the manufacturer for its test data. Nebraska Extension also notes that “less carbon is generally required to remove taste and odor-producing compounds than to remove THMs”, which is why a small pitcher that fixes the taste may not carry a TTHM claim.

Lead and PFAS, when the listing says so

Carbon can reduce lead, but Nebraska Extension notes that “Only very specialized AC filters effectively adsorb heavy metals” and that another medium is commonly added for lead. Many carbon block units carry “Lead Reduction” under NSF/ANSI 53 and some carry “PFOA Reduction” and “PFOS Reduction”; the model’s listing is the only way to know. Whether you need a PFAS filter at all is covered in our guide to which water filters remove PFAS.

Carbon formats and contact time

Carbon comes in pitchers, faucet-mounted units, countertop units, under-sink cartridges and point-of-entry tanks, and the format changes what it can do. Nebraska Extension explains that removal depends on contact time, which “is determined by the rate of water flow”, and on the amount of carbon. Pour-through and faucet-mounted units “are not as effective as other devices because contact time is limited due to the small amounts of carbon contained in the units”, which suits them to taste and odor rather than to health claims that need more carbon.

Under-sink units come in two plumbing arrangements. In an in-line unit on the cold supply to a mixing faucet, “the treated cold water mixes with the untreated hot water”, so only cold water from that faucet counts as treated. In a line-bypass unit, a separate faucet delivers treated water while the main faucet stays untreated, which Nebraska Extension says “increases the life of the carbon”. It also recommends a sediment filter ahead of any carbon unit, because “Sediment can easily and quickly clog the pores” of the carbon, and notes that when several contaminants compete for the same carbon, the less strongly held ones can break through first while others are still being removed.

What carbon does not touch

Nebraska Extension is direct: carbon filters “will not remove microbial contaminants (such as bacteria and viruses), calcium and magnesium (hard water minerals), fluoride, nitrate, and many other compounds”. Add sodium, chloride and total dissolved solids, which EPA’s secondary standards page assigns to “distillation, reverse osmosis, and electrodialysis”. Carbon also has a capacity limit. When it is full, contaminants pass through, and Nebraska Extension warns that the concentration in the “treated” water “may actually be higher than in the untreated water”. That is why cartridges are changed by gallons or months, not by taste.

What reverse osmosis removes, and why it comes with carbon stages

A membrane removes what carbon cannot: dissolved salts and metals such as sodium, nitrate, fluoride, arsenic and hardness. It is weaker on dissolved gases and some organic chemicals, which is why the carbon stages around it matter.

Dissolved solids, sodium, nitrate, fluoride and arsenic

Nebraska Extension’s table of contaminants removed by household RO units lists, among ions and metals, arsenic, barium, cadmium, calcium, chloride, chromium, copper, fluoride, lead, magnesium, nitrate, sodium and sulfate, plus protozoan cysts and radium and uranium. On NSF’s NSF/ANSI 58 listing, checked November 22, 2026, systems carry claims such as “Fluoride Reduction”, “Nitrate/Nitrite Reduction”, “Lead Reduction”, “TDS Reduction” and “Arsenic (Pentavalent)”. The arsenic claim comes with a note that the product “is intended for use only on water supplies that have been shown to be at or below the referenced concentration and valency of arsenic”, so a well owner needs a test that shows which form of arsenic is present.

A membrane removes a percentage, not everything. Nebraska Extension calls this the rejection rate and gives an example: with water at 40 mg/L nitrate and 85 percent rejection, 6 mg/L remains; at 80 mg/L, 12 mg/L remains, which is still above the 10 mg/L limit. The treated water has to be tested, not assumed.

What gets past a membrane

Nebraska Extension says dissolved gases such as hydrogen sulfide, the rotten egg odor, pass through, and “Some pesticides, solvents and volatile organic chemicals (VOCs) are not removed by RO”. It also says RO “can remove microorganisms” but “is not recommended for that use (i.e., only coliform-free water should be fed to the system)”, because bacteria damage membranes and pinhole leaks let contamination through.

How a household unit is built

Nebraska Extension describes the usual layout: a pretreatment filter, the membrane, a flow regulator, a post-treatment filter, a storage tank of 2 to 5 gallons and a separate faucet. A carbon prefilter protects thin film composite membranes, which “deteriorate in chlorinated water”. On unchlorinated water, such as most private wells, it advises a sediment prefilter only, because carbon there “can encourage microbial growth on the membrane surface”. A household membrane typically produces 10 to 35 gallons a day, and production drops 1 to 2 percent for every degree below 77 F. NSF’s listing gives each certified system’s daily production rate in gallons per day.

Pressure, recovery and temperature

An RO unit depends on the water pressure in your line. Nebraska Extension says incoming pressure “must be adequate to overcome the osmotic pressure and any back pressure” from the storage tank, that “Auxiliary pumps can be added to increase incoming water pressure as necessary”, and that “Generally, the higher the pressure difference across the membrane the better the rejection of contaminants and recovery rate”. A flow regulator on the drain line sets the balance: too slow and the membrane fouls, too fast and “excessive water flows down the drain”. Shutoff valves stop flow when the tank is full, which Nebraska Extension says matters “so excess water is not wasted”.

Cold water slows production. Nebraska Extension gives the example that well water at 45 F “would produce about half the amount of treated water” produced at 77 F. Use the daily production rate on the listing as a ceiling, and size the tank and the unit for the coldest month your water sees.

How you know a membrane is failing

A torn or fouled membrane does not change the taste of water in an obvious way. Nebraska Extension notes that “damaged RO membranes are not easily detected” and advises testing the treated water periodically. Many systems have a monitor for total dissolved solids, which compares the water before and after the membrane, and some count the gallons treated since the last membrane change. Microorganisms can also clog a membrane, which Nebraska Extension calls bio-fouling, so disinfect the system on the schedule and with the products the manufacturer specifies. A simple handheld TDS reading of the tap and of the RO faucet, taken when the unit is new and again every few months, shows whether the gap between them is shrinking.

Distillation and other options

Carbon and RO are not the only choices. EPA’s 2005 Filtration Facts describes distillers, which “heat water to the boiling point, and then collect the water vapor as it condenses”, leaving most chemical contaminants behind, though compounds that turn easily into gases “may remain in the water unless the system is specifically designed to remove them”. The CDC adds that bacteria “may grow on the system’s cooling coils while it is not being used”. NSF lists distillers under NSF/ANSI 62. For nitrate, our treatment selector also lists anion exchange; for arsenic, adsorptive media. These make sense when one contaminant is the whole problem and a membrane’s reject water or upkeep is a poor fit.

Read your water report first: Jackson’s 2025 results as a worked case

JXN Water’s 2025 report covers two systems with different water, and the right point-of-use choice differs between them. On the surface water system, the lines that stand out point to carbon; on the Maddox Road groundwater system, one line points to reverse osmosis.

JXN Water’s 2025 Water Quality Report, posted in June 2026, covers the City of Jackson surface water system (PWS ID MS0250008), supplied by the J.H. Fewell plant on the Pearl River and the O.B. Curtis plant on the Ross Barnett Reservoir, and the Maddox Road groundwater system (MS0250012), which draws from wells in the Sparta aquifer. If you are not sure which serves you, ask JXN Water. A broader reading of the report, including lead and boil-water notices, is in our guide to whether Jackson tap water is safe to drink.

System and report line (2025)ResultWhat it points to at the tap
Surface water: total trihalomethanesHighest running average 92.5 ppb (limit 80); violations in the first two quartersCarbon with a TTHM claim
Surface water: haloacetic acids (HAA5)Highest running average 69 ppb (limit 60); violations in the first two quartersCarbon or RO; ask for HAA5 test data, since no claim is named for it
Surface water: chloramineRunning average 3.0 ppm (range 0.1 to 5.40)Carbon with a chloramine claim, for taste
Surface water: sodium3.3 ppmNothing
Surface water: fluoride (added)0.98 ppm; within the 0.6 to 1.2 ppm optimal range all 12 monthsRO would remove it; carbon would not
Maddox Road: sodium151 ppm (range 139 to 151)RO with a TDS claim, if sodium matters to you
Maddox Road: HAA5 and TTHMHAA5 running average 63.1 ppb (violations in two quarters); TTHM 77.3 ppbCarbon
Maddox Road: chlorineRunning average 1.10 ppmCarbon with a chlorine claim, for taste
Surface water: yellow to brown water in summerSeasonal manganese (JXN notice, July 13, 2026)Neither; JXN calls it aesthetic and advises flushing
Source: JXN Water 2025 Water Quality Report (posted June 2026) and JXN Water notice of July 13, 2026, checked November 22, 2026. The right-hand column is general information, not advice for a particular home; lead is covered separately.

Surface water system: byproducts and chloramine point to carbon

The report lists violations of the TTHM and HAA5 running averages in early 2025, and repeats the standard health language: “Some people who drink water containing trihalomethanes in excess of the MCL over many years may experience problems with their liver, kidneys, or central nervous system, and may have an increased risk of getting cancer.” JXN says it is “evaluating corrective actions” and has “increased water quality monitoring”. The report also shows that the surface system disinfects with chloramine. Both facts point to carbon at the tap: a model whose listing carries “Trihalomethanes (TTHM) Reduction” and “Chloramine Reduction”. The sodium on this system is 3.3 ppm, so a membrane adds little.

Maddox Road: sodium points to reverse osmosis

The Maddox Road table lists sodium at 151 ppm, from samples in February 2025 ranging from 139 to 151 ppm. There is no enforceable limit for sodium. EPA’s 2018 standards and health advisories table gives a guidance value of 20 mg/L “for individuals on a 500 mg/day restricted sodium diet” and a taste threshold of 30 to 60 mg/L. One ppm equals one mg/L, so this water is above both. Carbon does nothing for sodium; the CDC lists sodium among the chemicals RO removes. Whether sodium matters for anyone in your household is a question for a doctor, not for this article.

Example (fictional). The Faircloth household, on the Maddox Road system, wants less sodium at the kitchen tap. They shortlist under-sink RO units whose NSF/ANSI 58 listing carries “TDS Reduction” and read each performance data sheet. Suppose one sheet shows 90 percent rejection for sodium in its test (a hypothetical figure): 151 ppm in would leave about 15 ppm out. At 85 percent it would leave about 23 ppm. Because a few percentage points move the result across the 20 mg/L guidance value, they choose the unit with the higher tested rejection and plan a laboratory sodium test of the treated tap after installation.

Lead on both systems

Lead is the one line on the report where both technologies can do the job, with the right claim. The report shows a 90th percentile lead level of 4.5 ppb on the surface system for January to June 2025, with individual results from non-detect to 192 ppb and 3 of 100 sites above the 15 ppb action level, and 4.1 ppb for July to December. On the Maddox Road system the 90th percentile was 2.1 ppb, with no site above the action level. The report says lead in drinking water “is primarily from materials and parts used in service lines and in home plumbing”, so a utility average says little about one house. MSDH’s Jackson water system page says any child five or younger and any pregnant woman “should use filtered water (NSF53 certified filter) or bottled water for drinking and cooking”. A carbon block with “Lead Reduction” under NSF/ANSI 53 or an RO unit with “Lead Reduction” under NSF/ANSI 58 both qualify; the choice between them comes from the rest of the report.

Fluoride, manganese and color

The surface system adds fluoride; the report says results were within the optimal range of 0.6 to 1.2 ppm in all 12 months of 2025, and the Maddox Road system did not add fluoride in 2025. An RO unit with a fluoride claim removes it, and the CDC notes that some filters remove “fluoride, which prevents cavities”. Discolored water is a different problem. JXN’s July 13, 2026 notice blamed a seasonal rise in manganese, called it “an aesthetic issue, not a health or safety issue”, and advised running cold water until it clears. EPA’s secondary standard for manganese is 0.05 mg/L, a guideline for color and taste. Neither carbon nor RO is the answer to seasonal color.

Private wells: when the choice tilts toward reverse osmosis

On a private well the problems that matter most are often dissolved ones, such as nitrate, arsenic or high dissolved solids, and those call for reverse osmosis or another targeted treatment, never carbon alone. Bacteria come first, though, because a membrane is not a disinfection step.

EPA’s 2005 Filtration Facts says that if your water comes from a household well, “EPA recommends annual water testing for nitrates and coliform bacteria”. The Mississippi State Department of Health tests private wells for bacteria only; minerals and chemicals go to a private laboratory, as our private well checklist sets out.

Nitrate and arsenic

EPA’s national standards set nitrate at 10 mg/L as nitrogen and warn that infants below six months who drink water above it “could become seriously ill and, if untreated, may die”. Arsenic’s limit is 0.010 mg/L (10 ppb). Carbon removes neither. The treatment selector lists RO with a nitrate claim, anion exchange or distillation for nitrate, and RO with an arsenic claim or adsorptive media for arsenic, noting that arsenic III “usually needs oxidation first”.

What to fix before a membrane

If a well has coliform bacteria, find and fix the source first, then add disinfection; Nebraska Extension says only coliform-free water should be fed to an RO system. On unchlorinated well water it advises a sediment prefilter rather than carbon ahead of the membrane. It also notes that RO wastewater “increases the load on the septic system”, and that hard water shortens membrane life unless a softener treats it first.

Example (fictional). The Bramlett household’s well report (fictional numbers) shows nitrate at 14 mg/L as nitrogen, no coliform bacteria, and hardness that the laboratory calls moderate. A carbon pitcher would change nothing about the nitrate. They choose an under-sink RO unit whose listing carries “Nitrate/Nitrite Reduction”, with a sediment prefilter because the well is not chlorinated. If the membrane rejected 85 percent, as in Nebraska Extension’s example, about 2.1 mg/L would remain; the laboratory test of the treated tap a month later is what tells them the real figure.

How much water reverse osmosis sends down the drain

A household RO unit sends between about one and ten gallons to the drain for every gallon it delivers, depending on its design. Carbon filters send none, which is one reason WaterSense says RO should not be the default.

The sources give a range. EPA’s PFAS filter page says RO “wastes about one gallon of water per every gallon treated”. WaterSense says “a typical point-of-use RO system will generate five gallons or more of reject water for every gallon of treated water produced”, that “Some inefficient units will generate up to 10 gallons”, and that WaterSense labeled units must send “2.3 gallons of water or less down the drain” per gallon. Nebraska Extension says most household systems are designed for 20 to 30 percent recovery, meaning 20 to 30 gallons of treated water from every 100 fed in.

Reject water a year at 3 gallons of treated water a day 1 to 1 EPA PFAS filter page 1,095 gal, about $11 2.3 to 1 WaterSense labeled limit 2,519 gal, about $25 5 to 1 Typical, per WaterSense 5,475 gal, about $55 10 to 1 Inefficient, per WaterSense 10,950 gal, about $110 Gallons of reject per gallon of treated water; cost at $10.00 per 1,000 gallons
Example (hypothetical) household drawing 3 gallons of RO water a day. Ratios: EPA, Identifying Drinking Water Filters Certified to Reduce PFAS, and EPA WaterSense, Point-of-Use Reverse Osmosis Systems. Rate: JXN Water combined water and sewer, first block, from March 23, 2026. Checked November 22, 2026.

The chart’s cost line uses JXN Water’s rates: from March 23, 2026, combined water and sewer for the first 50 CCF is $7.48 per CCF, and 1 CCF is 748 gallons, so $10.00 per 1,000 gallons. The money is small for one kitchen. The water is not always small: WaterSense says a labeled model saves on average “more than 3,100 gallons of water per year” compared with a typical one. It adds that it “does not intend to promote the installation of RO systems for all applications” and that “In some cases, other treatment methods that use little or no water, such as filtration, are sufficient to meet consumer treatment needs.”

Is reverse osmosis water healthy? Minerals, fluoride, sodium and taste

RO water is drinking water with most dissolved minerals removed; none of the agency sources used here treats that as a hazard, and EPA’s standards set limits on what water may contain, not minimum amounts of minerals. What changes is taste, fluoride, sodium and how the water behaves in pipes.

Minerals. The CDC says RO may reduce calcium, magnesium and potassium. EPA’s primary standards and its 15 secondary standards are upper limits or ranges; none sets a minimum calcium or magnesium content for drinking water. Food is where most people get those minerals, and anyone with a specific dietary concern should ask a doctor.

Taste. EPA’s 2005 Filtration Facts says distilled water “may taste flat to some people because the water’s natural minerals and dissolved oxygen often have been removed”, and RO water can strike people the same way. Some units add a mineral cartridge after the membrane. Treat it as a taste option, and check whether the listing for the unit still covers it as configured.

Fluoride. On a fluoridated system such as Jackson’s surface water system, an RO unit removes fluoride the utility adds for teeth, and the CDC notes that some filters remove “fluoride, which prevents cavities”. A carbon filter leaves it in place. If this matters to your family, ask your dentist.

Sodium. RO removes sodium; a water softener adds it. EPA’s 2005 fact sheet says softeners replace calcium and magnesium “with sodium or potassium ions”. A softened house with an RO unit at the kitchen tap gets soft water for the building and low-sodium water for drinking.

Pipes. Nebraska Extension says “Water treated by RO can be more corrosive than untreated water so special plumbing, in addition to the faucet, is installed with RO systems.” Use the tubing and faucet made for the unit and do not run RO water through old metal piping.

What each costs to buy and keep running

EPA puts carbon filters at $20 to $1,000 and RO systems at $150 to $1,000, not counting maintenance. Over a few years, the cartridges, the membrane and, for RO, the water decide the real cost.

The ranges come from EPA’s PFAS filter page, which adds that an RO system “Requires changing filter cartridges and the RO membrane” and that “Additional water treatment might be needed depending on your incoming water quality”. For carbon, the cost per year is the cartridge price times the number of changes; for RO, add the membrane and the reject water. WaterSense labeled RO units must have a membrane that lasts at least one year. Primary sources do not publish cartridge prices, so ask the seller for the price of each replacement element named on the listing.

Cost item Carbon filter Reverse osmosis unit
Purchase (EPA range, before maintenance) $20 to $1,000 $150 to $1,000
Replaced on a schedule One or two cartridges Sediment and carbon cartridges, post-filter, membrane
Water to the drain None About 1 to 10 gallons per gallon treated
Installation Pitcher or faucet: none; under-sink: a cold line and a faucet A cold line, a drain connection, a tank and a faucet
Output The flow rate on the listing 10 to 35 gallons a day for typical household membranes, less in cold water

Example (fictional). A kitchen carbon filter’s listing gives a rated capacity of 750 gallons, the manufacturer sets a six-month maximum, and the household draws 3 gallons a day. In the filter life calculator, the gallon rating is reached in 250 days and the time limit in 182 days, so the cartridge is replaced every 182 days (about 6.0 months), limited by time in service: 2.0 replacements a year. An RO unit’s prefilters are sized the same way, from their own rated gallons.

Nebraska Extension adds two cautions that cost nothing to follow. Carbon filters left idle “provide an excellent environment for bacterial growth”, and running water through the filter for 30 seconds after it has sat for hours limits that. And “the only way to be certain if a filter is successfully removing contaminants is by repeated testing of the filtered water”. Record each change and each test in a maintenance log.

For a break room, coffee line or ice machine

Businesses face the same choice, with more draw on each unit and equipment makers’ own water requirements on top. In a restaurant, office or clinic, carbon is the usual answer for taste, chlorine and chloramine; RO appears where the water’s dissolved solids cause scale or off-flavors in specific equipment, or where a lab result calls for it.

MSDH’s Guidelines for Water Use in Food Facilities, dated February 26, 2016, ask operators to flush drinking water points “before first consumption each day”, to keep filters on ice machines and drink dispensers “maintained and changed in accordance with the manufacturer’s recommendations”, and to use the NSF listings when buying a filter for equipment without one. On NSF’s directory the commercial category is listed separately as “Commercial and Food Service Water Treatment Equipment Utilizing Drinking Water (ASSE 1087)”. An ice machine can draw much more water through a cartridge than a break room faucet, so the same cartridge can reach its rated gallons much sooner on an ice line, and the replacement schedule has to follow each machine’s draw. Restaurants follow their health department’s instructions as well; this article gives no sanitation or health code advice.

Under the sink or for the whole building?

For most drinking water problems, the treatment belongs at the tap people drink from, and RO almost always does. Carbon is the one that sometimes belongs at the point where water enters the building, because some of what it removes is breathed in the shower, not just swallowed.

EPA’s 2005 Filtration Facts says that “some contaminants, such as radon, disinfection byproducts, and some organic chemicals, easily turn into gases and may pose a risk when inhaled, such as when showering”, and that a point-of-entry device can reduce them, along with problems such as scaling, staining or odor. Nebraska Extension recommends point-of-entry carbon for radon and volatile organic compounds, which “can easily vaporize from water in showers, washing machines and dishwashers”, and point-of-use units for contaminants that “pose a risk through ingestion, such as lead”. It calls point-of-entry RO “more costly to purchase, install and operate” than point-of-use.

A common arrangement follows from those sources: carbon or a softener at the point of entry for taste, chloramine or hardness throughout the building, and a certified unit at the kitchen tap for lead or for the dissolved substances only RO removes. Our page on whole-building filtration covers the point-of-entry side, drinking water systems covers each tap, ice machine and coffee line, and how it works shows the sediment, carbon, membrane and UV stages in order.

How to choose: a step-by-step checklist

Start from a result, not from a product. These steps take you from a water report to a specific, certified unit.

  1. Get the numbers. On city water, read your utility’s annual report, due by July 1. On a well, test at a certified laboratory, including coliform bacteria and nitrate.
  2. Mark each line that matters. Anything above a limit, near one, or behind a complaint about taste, odor or scale.
  3. Sort the lines. Chlorine, chloramine, TTHM, solvents and taste go to carbon. Sodium, nitrate, fluoride, arsenic and total dissolved solids go to RO. Lead and PFOA and PFOS can go to either, with the right claim. Bacteria go to disinfection first.
  4. Pick the smallest tool that covers every line. If carbon covers the list, choose carbon. If one line needs RO, choose an RO unit whose carbon stages also cover the carbon lines.
  5. Confirm each claim in the certifier’s directory, by model and cartridge number.
  6. Check the practical fit. Space under the sink, a drain for RO, a cold line, a faucet hole, and daily production against what you drink and cook with.
  7. Price the upkeep. Cartridges by the filter life calculator, the membrane, and for RO the reject water on your bill.
  8. Test the treated tap after installation, and keep a log.

Five common mismatches

  • RO for chlorine taste alone. A carbon unit with a chlorine claim does that without a membrane, a tank or reject water.
  • A chlorine-rated filter on chloraminated water. Chloramine is a separate NSF/ANSI 42 claim; check for it if your utility uses chloramine, as Jackson’s surface system does.
  • Carbon for nitrate, sodium or fluoride. Carbon does not remove them, whatever the box says about “cleaner” water.
  • RO on a well with coliform bacteria. Fix and disinfect first; a membrane is not a disinfection step.
  • Changing cartridges by taste. Carbon can pass contaminants long before taste or pressure changes; change by rated gallons or months.

The treatment selector gives the matching treatment and test for one problem at a time. If you would rather have every tap in a home or building matched to a laboratory result, a water review starts there, and you can get in touch to ask about one. More guides are on the drinking water hub.

Have a building in mind?

If this article describes a question about your home, property or business, tell us about the building. A project starts with a water review and a written summary of what we found.