Treatment selector: which treatment fits which problem
One problem at a time: what can address it, what does not, the test that confirms it, and what changes for a private well.
For: Homeowners, well owners and building managers deciding what treatment to buy

Selector
Every treatment removes some things and not others. A softener does nothing for lead, a carbon filter does nothing for nitrate, and boiling makes some problems worse. This selector answers one narrow question for one problem at a time: which kinds of treatment can address it, which cannot, and which test confirms it. It is for homeowners, well owners and building managers who have a test result or a notice in hand and are about to buy equipment.
How it works
Choose a problem and your water source. The selector returns four rows: what can address it, what does not, the test to confirm, and a note for your source. The fourteen problems are lead; chlorine taste and odor; chloramine; PFAS (PFOA and PFOS); nitrate; arsenic; hardness and scale; iron and manganese; bacteria (coliform); sediment and cloudiness; hydrogen sulfide (rotten egg odor); cysts (Cryptosporidium and Giardia); fluoride; and total dissolved solids.
The answers name the NSF/ANSI standard a product would be certified under. NSF’s listings use these titles:
| Standard | Title |
|---|---|
| NSF/ANSI 42 | Drinking Water Treatment Units, Aesthetic Effects |
| NSF/ANSI 44 | Cation Exchange Water Softeners |
| NSF/ANSI 53 | Drinking Water Treatment Units, Health Effects |
| NSF/ANSI 55 | Ultraviolet Microbiological Water Treatment Systems |
| NSF/ANSI 58 | Reverse Osmosis Drinking Water Treatment Systems |
| NSF/ANSI 62 | Drinking Water Distillation Systems |
| NSF/ANSI 401 | Emerging Compounds/Incidental Contaminants |
Certification is claim-specific. A product listed under NSF/ANSI 53 is certified only for the contaminants named in its listing, so check the listing for the exact contaminant, not just the standard number.
The inputs
- The water problem. Take it from a laboratory report (the water test reader shows what is above a limit), a utility notice or the utility’s Consumer Confidence Report. Taste alone is a poor guide.
- Your source. City water or a private well. The answer about treatment is the same; the advice on testing differs.
The default example
The selector opens with “Lead” and “City water” selected, and returns:
- What can address it: Point-of-use filter certified for lead reduction under NSF/ANSI 53, or a reverse osmosis unit certified under NSF/ANSI 58 with a lead claim. Run the cold tap before use after water has sat for hours.
- What does not: Water softeners, sediment filters and boiling do not remove lead; boiling concentrates it.
- Test to confirm: First-draw sample from the kitchen tap, analyzed by a certified laboratory.
- Your source: For city water, read the utility’s annual Consumer Confidence Report and any notices first; the problem may start in your building’s own pipes.
This matches EPA’s lead guidance: “boiling water does not remove lead,” and a filter should be one “certified to remove lead,” with cartridges replaced on schedule. For Jackson, MSDH’s Jackson Water System page, written after 2021 lead sampling and still posted when checked on November 22, 2026, advises children five and under and pregnant women to use “filtered water (NSF53 certified filter) or bottled water,” along with running the cold tap and cleaning aerators.
What each method does and does not remove
CDC’s guidance on choosing home water filters summarizes the main methods. Microfiltration removes parasites but not viruses or chemicals. Ultrafiltration removes parasites and bacteria. Reverse osmosis removes parasites, bacteria, viruses and some chemicals such as lead, copper and sodium. Distillation removes many chemicals but not reliably some volatile organic compounds. UV light with pre-filtration is effective against parasites, bacteria and viruses but does not remove chemicals. Softeners remove calcium and magnesium but not microbes.
Limits and next steps
PFAS needs extra care. EPA’s April 2024 fact sheet says filter certifications “focus on removing the chemicals PFOA and PFOS” and do “not yet indicate that a filter will remove PFAS down to the levels EPA has now set.”
The selector handles one problem at a time. Real water often has two or three, and the order of treatment matters: sediment before carbon, iron removal before a softener, filtration before UV. That order is what a design sets. Maredes explains the stages on how it works and specifies them by certification for drinking water systems at the tap and whole-building filtration at the service entry. Once a filter is in, the filter life calculator sets the change interval, and the water is tested again to confirm the treatment works.
Start with a water review.
Tell us about the building: what it is, who uses it, where the water comes from and what you would like to change. We reply with questions and a time to walk the building with you.